Program Review Tools for Readers
Please note: Dates on this page are also posted on the Program Review Timeline which is on the Program Review Committee homepage.
READING PROCESS
- Read all Program Reviews assigned to you. A link to the program review drafts appears at the bottom of this page, and your names are there.
- Reading assignments within a division are occasionally non-sequential, so make sure to read all Program Reviews with your name next to them.
- As you read, fill out the Division Summary Template for the Program Reviews you read.
The Template is an online document that will allow you to take notes on the information
in the Program Reviews you read.
- A link to the Template for each division appears at the bottom of this page.
- Please make sure to use your assigned color (noted on the Template) to take notes.
- Readers will receive assignments by November 11.
- The November 13th PRC meeting (3:00-4:30 pm) will be a work session; it is required for all PRC members, and all readers are invited to attend.
- All reading assignments will be primary readers. The Deans will be the second reader.
- Primary readers have the following responsibilities:
- Read the assigned Program Review in detail
- Record priority information from that Program Review thoroughly on the Summary document
- Fill out the following sections:
- Section A: Program Specific Notes
- Section B: Program Specific Notes
- Section C
- All other sections will be completed at the division summary meeting. If you have ideas for those sections, you may make notes in those sections to be used during the meeting.
- Secondary (dean) readers have the following responsibilities:
- Read all Program Reviews for your division in detail
- Review information from the primary reader in sections A, B, and C. Add or edit any information as necessary/desired.
- All other sections will be completed at the division summary meeting. If you have ideas for those sections, you may make notes in those sections to be used during the meeting.
All readers (including PRC readers, SLO/SAO Comittee readers, deans, and other readers) should finish posting their comments on the Division Summary Template by Friday of Week 1 of Spring semester.
Meeting with Dean
Before the end of the fall semester, the Program Review member should arrange a meeting with the dean of the division in which they are reading Program Reviews. The date should be decided by the final day of fall course instruction so that it is on everyone's calendars for the start of spring semester.
The dean and all PRC readers for the division should attend this meeting. Meetings should take place during Week 2 of Spring semester and should last about 1-1.5 hours.
- All attendees should be prepared to access the Division Summary document during the meeting.
- The goal of this meeting is to review the readers' notes on the Division Summary form and complete a final or close-to-final draft of the Division Summary (see "Writing the Summary" below).
- If the readers want to suggest revisions to a Program Review, the dean should communicate these suggestions to the program by December. They may do so in person, by email, or using the Suggestions for Revision Form.
During the Meeting
- At the meeting, the assembled team will write the Division Summary on the same reading form.
- To create the summary, edit your Division Summary template with all the readers' notes,
adding and deleting information as needed.
- If you would like to preserve your team's notes to use as you work, make a copy of the summary template with the notes (using "Save as" under "file" on MS Word).
- Name the copy "Division Summary Notes" or something similar and share it with the meeting members to use alongside the edited summary document.
- Meeting Tasks
- Review the primary readers' notes on sections A, B, and C of the summary document.
- Complete the following sections:
- Section A: Overarching themes
- Section B: Overarching themes
- Section D
- Section E
- The summary should ideally be completed by the end of the meeting! If it is not completed, any remaining work should be done by the dean; such work should be minimal.
- After this step the PRC members' duties are completed.
- The Division Summaries are due to Karin Spirn on January 31. The Dean should email Karin to let her know the summary is complete. She will change the editing option to "Commenter"
- Summaries should be discussed during the division meetings in February or shared with the division in another way. Deans may choose to update summaries based on division feedback; any updates should be sent to the PRC chair by February 25.
MATERIALS
- Program Review Drafts 2024
- Division Summary Templates
- Suggestion for Revisions Form
Program Review Committee
Committee Meetings
2nd & 4th Wednesdays
3:00 - 4:30 p.m. in TBD
For more information please contact:
Karin Spirn
Program Review Committee Chair
(925) 424-1219